Few songs manage to touch the soul as deeply or as universally as the gospel hymn How Great Thou Art. With its sweeping melody and powerful lyrics, it has remained a staple in both religious and musical communities for generations. Over the years, countless artists have taken on the challenge of performing this iconic piece, each bringing their own style and emotional depth. Yet among all these renditions, one particular performance has stood out and etched itself into the hearts of millions — the unforgettable duet by Vince Gill and Carrie Underwood at the 2011 Academy of Country Music’s “Girls’ Night Out: Superstar Women of Country” event.
Held as a tribute to the legendary women of country music, this special evening was more than just a concert — it was a celebration of talent, influence, and the profound impact female artists have had on the genre. The event recognized several powerhouse names in country music, including Reba McEntire, Miranda Lambert, Martina McBride, Jennifer Nettles, and Carrie Underwood herself. These women have helped shape the sound of country music over the decades, breaking barriers and inspiring a new generation of artists along the way.
Among a night filled with incredible moments and emotional tributes, the performance of How Great Thou Art by Vince Gill and Carrie Underwood became the undeniable highlight. As the stage lights softened and the first notes of the hymn began to play, the audience immediately knew they were about to witness something extraordinary. Vince Gill, with his smooth, emotionally rich voice, began the song with a quiet reverence, drawing the audience in. When Carrie Underwood joined in, the atmosphere shifted — her powerful vocals soared, blending perfectly with Gill’s steady tone, creating a harmony that felt both intimate and grand.
There was something profoundly moving about their delivery. The emotion in their voices wasn’t just for show; it was clear they felt every word they sang. The audience responded with utter silence during the performance — not out of indifference, but because they were fully immersed in the moment. Every note carried weight, every lyric resonated, and by the time they reached the final chorus, it was hard to find a dry eye in the room.
When the last chord faded, the reaction was immediate and overwhelming. The entire audience rose to their feet in a spontaneous standing ovation, applauding not just the technical brilliance of the performance, but the emotional depth and sincerity that Gill and Underwood had brought to the stage. For many in attendance, it was more than just a musical highlight — it was a spiritual experience.
Even more remarkable is how this performance has stood the test of time. Though it took place over a decade ago, it continues to be referenced and shared as one of the greatest live renditions of the hymn ever recorded. It’s not uncommon to see fans online reminiscing about the moment, praising the raw emotion and unmatched vocal talent of both performers. The video of their performance has garnered millions of views, with comments pouring in from people around the world who felt moved, inspired, and uplifted by what they saw and heard.
This enduring legacy speaks to the power of music — especially a song like How Great Thou Art, which holds deep meaning for so many. Originally penned in the late 1800s and translated into English in the mid-20th century, the hymn praises the magnificence of creation and the greatness of God. Its lyrics speak to awe, reverence, and gratitude — emotions that transcend time, culture, and denomination. When performed with authenticity, as it was that night by Gill and Underwood, it becomes something even more profound.
Carrie Underwood, known for her powerful voice and strong Christian faith, has often spoken about how meaningful this song is to her. She’s performed it on other occasions as well, but it’s this particular duet that remains a fan favorite. Her ability to convey both strength and vulnerability in a single performance is what makes her such a compelling artist, and when paired with Vince Gill’s steady presence and heartfelt delivery, the result is nothing short of magical.
It’s also worth acknowledging the role events like Girls’ Night Out play in preserving and honoring the contributions of women in country music. Far too often, female artists have had to fight for equal recognition in the industry, despite their immense talent and influence. By spotlighting these legends and giving them a platform to be celebrated, the Academy of Country Music helped reaffirm their rightful place at the center of the genre’s history and future.
Looking back, it’s clear that this performance wasn’t just a musical highlight — it was a cultural moment. It reminded audiences of the emotional power of live music, the importance of honoring those who came before, and the beauty of artists coming together to create something truly unforgettable. For anyone who has not yet seen it, this is a performance worth experiencing — not just hearing, but truly feeling.
You can watch it in the video linked below and judge for yourself. Chances are, you’ll agree that this was one of the finest performances ever given of How Great Thou Art. And even if you’ve seen it before, it’s the kind of moment that never loses its impact — a shining example of what music can be when it’s performed with heart, passion, and a deep sense of purpose.
